What is the Advantage and Disadvantage of Ducted Dehumidifier

Maintaining indoor air quality and comfort is essential in any setting, from residential homes to commercial spaces. Dehumidifiers are crucial as they remove extra moisture from the air. This helps prevent mold and mildew, protects building materials, and keeps the environment healthier.

You can find more information on our web, so please take a look.

There are two primary types of dehumidifiers to consider: ducted and non-ducted. Each serves different needs depending on the size of the space, integration with existing systems, and specific humidity control requirements.

What are ducted dehumidifiers?

Ducted dehumidifiers are designed to connect directly to a building’s heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) system through ductwork. This setup allows them to draw moist air from various building parts, process it to remove moisture, and then redistribute the drier air back into the space.

This process involves several key components, such as a fan, compressor, evaporator, and condenser. The air, once dehumidified, can either rejoin the main airflow or be directed to specific areas. This makes ducted systems effective for managing humidity on a large scale or in targeted zones.

What is the Purpose of the Duct?

Duct dehumidifiers usually feature two ducts, although some models are designed to connect to just the outlet duct. The inlet duct is primarily used with air circulation and ventilation fan systems. It serves to move and transport air and increase airflow. It removes contaminated air from an enclosed area and exhausts it outside the controlled area.

The outlet duct changes the airflow direction to the outside. In addition, installing the dehumidifier in a specific area and venting the indoor air through this duct reduces the impact of machine operation noise on the active region.

An example of a ducted unit is the Sentinel HDi90 dehumidifier, which be connected to the inlet and outlet ducts. Here is a photo of it when it is connected.

How do ducted and non-ducted dehumidifiers compare?

Choosing between ducted and non-ducted dehumidifiers depends on specific needs, the layout of your space, and personal preferences for maintenance and installation. Each type offers distinct advantages and challenges.

Below are the pros and cons of each system. Knowing this can help you make the most economical decision for your living environment.

Ducted Dehumidifiers

Pros: They are efficient for large spaces, can be integrated with existing HVAC systems for whole-home control, and are less visible and quieter than non-ducted units.

Cons: Higher initial installation cost, more complex installation process, typically requires professional maintenance.

Non-Ducted Dehumidifiers

Pros: It is more portable and flexible in placement, easier for non-professionals to install and maintain, and lower in initial cost.

Cons: It may be less efficient in large spaces, more visible and noisier. It may use more power if dehumidifying a specific space.

Note: Ducted dehumidifiers and non-ducted dehumidifiers are not absolute. Some dehumidifiers will come with a ducted panel, and when you don’t connect the ducts, they function as non-ducted dehumidifiers.

When to use a duct dehumidifier?

Large or Multiple Rooms

Ducted dehumidifiers like the Sentinel HD55S provide superior moisture control in large or segmented spaces. By connecting to ductwork, these systems can distribute dehumidified air more effectively across extensive areas, maintaining balanced humidity levels.

Integrated HVAC Systems

Homes with existing HVAC ductwork can benefit from the seamless integration of a ducted dehumidifier. Ducted dehumidifiers integrate into a building’s existing HVAC infrastructure, maintaining aesthetics and minimizing visual disruption. They are typically installed in non-living spaces like basements or above ceilings, making them quieter than non-ducted models.

It is ideal for areas where noise levels and visual harmony are crucial, such as residential spaces and professional environments that demand quiet.

Basements and Crawl Spaces

These areas often require powerful moisture control solutions. Duct dehumidifiers provide tailored humidity management in them, especially in complex layouts. It improves upper space indoor air quality by removing excess moisture and associated air pollutants such as allergens and mold spores. This improvement can have a direct positive effect on the health and comfort of building occupants.

Conclusion

Choosing between ducted and non-ducted dehumidifiers involves evaluating specific environmental needs, space configurations, and personal preferences for installation and maintenance. Ducted dehumidifiers, integrated into the building’s HVAC system, are especially beneficial for large or complex spaces requiring consistent and extensive humidity control.

If you want to learn more, please visit our website Ant.

They offer advantages such as enhanced air quality, energy efficiency, and seamless integration into existing infrastructures, making them less obtrusive and quieter. Although the initial setup for a ducted dehumidifier might be higher than non-ducted units, the long-term energy savings and durability often offset the initial costs. Also, maintaining optimal humidity levels can prevent damage to building materials and contents, reducing maintenance and repair expenses.

There are a couple of really important things to understand when ducting a dehumidifier. Getting one or both of these things wrong can throw off your entire dehumidifier install. Instead of just telling you the different ways you can install a dehumidifier, let’s talk through some dehumidifier basics, which will help us understand why it’s so easy to make mistakes with them. The legend Allison Bailes wrote an article here that covers much of the same material if you’re interested in another perspective. 

Dehumidifiers ADD Sensible Heat

Although dehumidifiers remove moisture, they do that at a cost, and that cost is hot air somewhere else. I think about dehumidifiers as essentially window units. If you took a window unit and stuck it in the middle of your room on the floor, one side would blow cold air, and one side would blow hot air. Normally, we blow the hot air outside, but with a dehumidifier, we cool the air off and then use the “hot air” to reheat the cold air once we’ve knocked the moisture out of it. Here’s an example of a dehumidifier refrigerant cycle. Because no system is 100% efficient, “waste” heat is generated from the fan motors and compressor—this has the net effect of adding sensible heat to the dehumidifier supply air. 

This information can be used to either great advantage or disadvantage. Do you want to add warmer, dryer air to the return or supply side of an HVAC system while it is running? What happens if you do? 

What happens is you derate your HVAC equipment’s ability to dehumidify. Let’s take a look at why. Imagine, like in the picture above, your dehumidifier is running. Here’s an example from an actual dehumidifier. It dehumidifies the air coming in, which was 76°F at 65% RH, and after working its magic, the discharge air is 98°F and 30% RH. 

Now, your dehumidifier discharge air mixes back in with the rest of your return air. The cumulative effect is a decrease in the total moisture content of the air and an increase in sensible temperature. Then, your HVAC coil steps in and tries to do its job, but you just made that harder. 

In order to remove moisture from the air, the evaporator coil needs to be below the dew point. But you’ve already removed moisture from the air, lowering the dew point and making it harder for your HVAC system to run a cold enough coil to hit the dew point and get that additional dehumidification you want. 

Let the dehumidifier and HVAC systems dehumidify independently. Running the pre-treated dehumidified air through the evaporator coil ends up being a net loss.

Dehumidifiers Have Wimpy Fans

Ok, maybe “wimpy” isn’t the right word, but their fans are much less powerful than the one it is connected to and interacts with—the HVAC fan. Let’s take a look at the blower performance data for this Santa Fe dehumidifier:

Now, imagine you duct the supply of the dehumidifier into the supply of the HVAC system, like the example below. If the supply-side static pressure of the system is high, your dehumidifier will have trouble overcoming that pressure while the HVAC system is running. 

The dehumidifier fan has to overcome the TOTAL external static pressure, so the worst setup from a fan performance perspective is ducting dehumidifier return to HVAC return and dehumidifier supply to HVAC supply because then your dehumidifier has to overcome the negative pressure of the return AND the positive pressure of the supply side.

You can mitigate this risk by putting the dehumidifier supply as close to the equipment as possible to take advantage of the Coanda effect, as described here, but it is something to be very cautious about. Another recommended option is a collar with a scoop, like this one.

Turning Weakness Into Strength

Is there a way to turn the weaknesses of a dehumidifier into a strength? To turn that frown upside down? Enter the “injection” method, where low static pressure and low entering air temperatures create the (potential?) perfect scenario.

In this scenario, both the dehumidifier return and supply are ducted into the supply side of the HVAC supply ductwork. The benefits are you now have return air coming into the dehumidifier at almost 100% relative humidity, meaning the dehumidifier doesn’t have to do much work to cool the air a little more, hit 100% RH, and start pulling moisture out of the air. 

In addition to this “boost” mode dehumidification, we also get the added benefit of no static pressure. Yes, the supply plenum can have high static pressure, but if the supply and the return for the dehumidifier are tied in or “experiencing” the same pressure, the net effect is 0. Static pressure is pressure in reference to another pressure. If you put both static pressure probes in the supply ductwork, you will read 0. Many times, we read supply static pressure in reference to ambient pressure, which is why we see a difference. What pressure we are referencing matters a lot. 

No Free Lunch

Although the injection method seems almost too good to be true, it does have a downside. Because you are introducing 50–55°F air into the return side of the dehumidifier, the cabinet could sweat a lot more. 

If you’re going to introduce fresh air, this method is tricky as well. Your dehumidifier fan may not be able to overcome the supply side pressure enough to draw air through the fresh air vent. Consider a separate method of bringing in ventilation air, such as a powered fan.

—Matt Bruner