Piston ring choice - Don Terrill's Speed-Talk
Piston ring choice - Don Terrill's Speed-Talk
Piston ring choice
If you are looking for more details, kindly visit Dongya.
Dear Friends,I am mainly building 4 cylinder European old school petrol engines like the Ford Sohc ( 2.0 lt Pinto ), Kent Xflow, Fiat DOHC, Sohc, Opel, etc.
These builds are sometimes for mainly road going steet and hotrod engines but also sometimes for so called high revving ( up to rpm ) high CR ( up to 12,5:1 ), hotter operating competition engines for strictly competition use. ( mainly European style on and off road rallying )
Although, due to the nature of the builds, competition engines do require frequent tear down and rebuild, total reliability is the most important target in our builds.
During these builds; we either use the existing cast iron block or ductile iron sleeves/liners. Therefore, I would like to base my question on 2 different cylinder materials and 2 different usage accordingly.
We mainly use various brands of forged pistons and we use cast pistons for the road/fast road/mild hotrod engines.
So, in the light of the above information, and since there are many different ring materials (phosphate coated cast iron, moly coated, chrome coated, ductile iron, steel nitrided, etc ) I would like to ask your help for the best combination of the rings to match for the purpose and the given cylinder/block materials ( cast iron and ductile iron sleeved block ).
It would be great if you could base your advices in the following form:
Cast iron original block/cylinder :
Fast road/hotrod engine with cast or hyperteutic pistons
Competiton engine with forged pistons
Ductile iron sleeved block
Fast road/hotrod engine with cast or hyperteutic pistons
Competition engine with forged pistons
Regards
Re: Piston ring choice
I do some Lotus/Cortina/Kent motors for road racing I'm sure very similar to what you do, I really like the thin metric ring combo that we get with our custom JE pistons, gas nitrited steel top ring, cast Napier second ring. Sold as JE Pro Seal, made by NPR in Japan. Nate @steeldustmachineEngine Machinist
Re: Piston ring choice
I agree. If you can get your bore to a metric diameter I don't think that you can beat those NPR rings. And they can be had, for example, in bores like : 83mm,83.5, 84,84.5 and sometimes in certain bores .25 mm over. CP uses mostly 1mm, 1.2mm and 2.8mm oil but there are some available in smaller widths.Re: Piston ring choice
Forged aluminum pistons are readily available for most applications and custom pieces are very easy to design and manufacture, whereas cast pistons are limited to what is already available. Forged pistons are also very attractively priced - I'm sure that Dcal can attest to that . . . . .As far as ring packages go, the ductile iron, barrel-faced, plasma moly top ring; cast iron reverse twist taper-face second ring and three-piece oil ring assembly has been the logical choice for many years. However, steel top ring, barrel-faced, Nitrate coated is the modern/current choice, along with cast-iron Napier, taper face second ring and the old reliable three-piece oil ring assembly. Note however, that many engine builders are currently experimenting with steel two-piece oil rings, with very good results.
Modern thinking is also going towards thin metric thicknesses such as 1.5mm, 1.2mm 1.0mm, .8mm compression rings and 3.0mm and 2.0mm oil ring assemblies. As stated in previous posts, NPR is becoming a major supplier of thin metric rings for metric applications. NPR coverage for domestic engine applications is somewhat limited (other than GM LS; Ford Modular; Mopar HEMI, etc) however new sized are being released almost daily. Bill
Perfect Circle Doctor of Motors certification
SAE Member (30 years)
ASE Master Certified Engine Machinist (+ two otherASE Master Certifications)
AERA Certified Professional Engine Machinist
Re: Piston ring choice
Moly face is good for wide rings, and minimal cylinder wear in soft blocks, so all the old school V8 guys love them.For relatively NARROW metric rings, it's pretty much all chrome face NPR, or nitrided steel. Moly facing is quite amazing, but brittle, and cannot flex very much.
It will depend on the piston, what rings it will accept. If they take wide rings, then try moly. Wide chrome ring is usually terrible choice unless operating in dusty conditions and you are solving a wear problem.
There should be no real difference in ductile or plain iron, both are the same to a ring, but if the cylinders are becoming more flexible you may need to go to narrower rings to get a good seal. and if the cylinder material is harder or softer, you may need to hone differently to get a good finish.
How To Choose the Best Piston Ring for Your Application
Advancements in piston ring technology over the past few decades have significantly improved materials, coatings, edge profiles, and ring thickness, enhancing oil control, sealing, and wear. However, these advancements only perform optimally when used correctly. A basic street engine for cruising requires a vastly different ring package than a 1,000-horsepower turbocharged engine. Selecting the right piston rings for your build involves numerous considerations. While some piston kits include rings, higher-performance builds often require rings as a separate purchase.
There's no single “best” ring package. Choosing the right one depends on factors such as engine use, power level, compression, fuel type, and any power adders. The ideal ring package ensures proper sealing, durability, and minimal friction loss while maximizing power and oil control. It must also wear appropriately for the engine's intended use.
Below is a breakdown of modern piston ring materials, types, and coatings to help you select the best rings for your build. If a professional is assembling your short block, it's always wise to follow their recommendations for your reciprocating assembly.
What Are Piston Rings Made Of?
When it comes to piston ring material types there are a few ring materials no longer used or only used in specialty applications now. Currently the most common piston ring material types for automotive engines are cast iron, ductile iron, and steel. While steel does have the highest tensile strength, don't count out cast iron or ductile iron rings for the right applications. For example, if you're performing a basic “hone and ring” job to drop back into your daily driver there is no need for the added expense of ductile iron or steel rings.
What Are the Different Types of Piston Rings?
Modern pistons utilize three distinct types of piston rings, each serving a specific function. At the top is the top compression ring, the primary seal between the piston and the combustion chamber wall. Below this is the second or intermediate compression ring, which supports the top ring by enhancing combustion chamber sealing, aiding heat transfer, and scraping excess oil from the cylinder wall. Lastly, the oil control ring at the bottom regulates the oil delivered to the cylinder wall for lubrication and cooling.
It's worth noting that different materials can be used for the top and intermediate compression rings within various ring packages. For example, a package might feature a ductile iron top ring paired with a cast iron intermediate compression ring.
Top and Intermediate Compression Ring Types:
- Conventional Ring: Features gaps that can be adjusted for various applications (N/A, nitrous, etc.). This style is often file-fit by engine builders to meet specific final specifications. Refer to the ring gap section below for further details.
- Gapless Top Ring: Designed to enhance horsepower and crankcase vacuum, this type is mainly used in N/A engine applications to improve cylinder filling through better ring sealing. For optimal performance, position the gapless ring close to the intake valve. Total Seal Gapless rings are available for engine project builds.
- Gapless 2nd Ring: Ideal for turbocharged, supercharged, or boxer engines. With forced induction aiding cylinder filling, the gapless 2nd ring is effective in keeping heat and contaminants out of the oil pan. While a gapless top ring can also be used in boosted setups, it performs best in N/A applications.
- Gas Ported Top Ring: Enhances horsepower by improving ring seal. This ring features lateral gas ports machined into its top, bringing the benefits of gas porting to any piston. Suitable for both street and competition engines.
Oil Control Ring Types:
- One-Piece Oil Control Rings: Rarely used today, these function like compression rings, with cylinder wall tension derived from the ring's cross-section. Featuring a U-shaped design, the center groove directs excess oil back to the crankcase. They are available in various ring profiles.
- Two-Piece Oil Control Rings: Consist of a coil spring placed into the piston's oil ring groove, followed by a specialized oil control ring over the spring. The spring provides tension to press the ring against the cylinder wall. These are also available in various profiles.
- Three-Piece Oil Control Rings: Composed of a pair of support rails with an expander in between to provide rail tension. The expander pushes the rails outward, allowing them to act as scrapers to remove excess oil from the cylinder wall and return it to the crankcase. This design is the most commonly used today.
For more information, please visit piston ring manufacturer.
Oil Ring Tension:
When selecting piston rings, you can specify the desired oil ring tension to suit your engine build specifications. The options include standard tension, low tension, and high tension oil rings.
- Standard Tension:Oil ring tension varies by thickness. For instance, a standard tension 3/16 oil ring has a higher tension than a standard tension 3.0mm oil ring. Generally, thicker oil rings have higher standard tension for their size.
- Low Tension: Although also thickness-dependent, low tension does not always fall below the next size down in oil ring tension. For example, a low tension 3/16 oil ring might measure 15 lb/ft, while a standard tension 3.0mm oil ring measures 12 lb/ft. Proper use of lower tension oil rings can increase horsepower and enhance cylinder bore longevity.
- High Tension:High tension values also depend on thickness but operate inversely. For example, a high tension 3.0mm oil ring might measure 15 lb/ft, while a standard tension 3/16 oil ring could reach 23 lb/ft. High tension oil rings are ideal for boosted and nitrous applications, helping to mitigate oil-related detonation risks.
Types of Piston Ring Profiles and Installation
Piston ring profiles refer to the outer edge of the ring that seals against the combustion chamber wall. Various profiles are designed for specific functions, such as enhanced sealing or improved oil control. While these profiles can be hard to distinguish visually, manufacturers mark their rings with a dot or the word "TOP" to indicate the correct installation orientation. Note that this marking shows the correct orientation of the ring itself, not its position on the piston. Always install rings with the dot or "TOP" facing up.
- Square Face: Provides excellent sealing but experiences higher wear over time, eventually wearing into a barrel shape. Typically used for the top ring.
- Barrel Face: Offers the best sealing properties with lower wear and longer life, commonly used on the top ring.
- Taper Face: Found on the second compression ring, this profile features a 2-4 degree taper to assist in scraping oil off the cylinder wall.
- Napier Face: Features a groove machined under the second compression ring to enhance oil removal from the cylinder wall.
The top compression ring is generally a barrel face design, while the second ring often features a taper or Napier face. These varying profiles are selected to optimize each ring's performance for its specific function.
Determining the Correct Piston Ring Size
The piston ring diameter must match the cylinder bore. If the cylinder has been overbored, you'll need to order the corresponding oversized piston and ring set. For instance, a standard 4.00-inch bore machined to 4.030 inches will require 4.030-inch pistons and rings. File-to-fit rings are sized +.005 inches over the bore diameter, allowing precise adjustment of the end gap for performance applications.
Understanding Standard Piston Ring End Gap
End gap specifications are usually provided by the ring manufacturer, but a common guideline is . inches of gap per inch of bore diameter for the top ring in naturally aspirated engines. For example, a 4.00-inch bore engine would require an .018-inch top ring gap. Second rings typically have a slightly larger gap, about .006 inches per inch of bore diameter.
The end gap must accommodate ring expansion due to combustion heat, ensuring the ring ends do not touch, which could lead to scuffing or breakage. Using a piston ring gap filer is essential for evenly filing both ends of the ring to achieve the proper gap.
Are Thicker Piston Rings Better?
Traditionally, piston rings have been measured in fractional inches, with common sizes being 5/64-inch, 1/16-inch, or .043-inch for top and second rings, and 3/16-inch for oil rings. Modern engines, however, have transitioned to thinner, metric-sized rings, such as 1.5mm to 1.0mm for compression rings and 3.0mm to 2.0mm for oil rings. Custom pistons can use even thinner rings, down to .5mm (.020 inches).
Thinner piston rings offer several advantages:
- Increased Horsepower and Torque: Reduced friction from thinner rings contributes to better engine performance.
- Reduced Weight and Compression Height: Modern piston and ring designs allow for more efficient engine operation and lighter components.
While thicker rings require piston ring installation pliers for proper handling, thinner rings benefit from the same careful installation to avoid damage. Only the oil ring's top and bottom rails should ever be “spiraled” onto the piston; compression rings must always be installed with dedicated tools to ensure accuracy and prevent deformation.
Contact us to discuss your requirements of Custom Piston Ring. Our experienced sales team can help you identify the options that best suit your needs.